Decision Model for Furnishing Tunnels with safety technical Systems

Part 2:  Assessing 2 Furnishing Variants with the Aid of an integrated decision Model

In the first part it was shown how the evaluation and selection of safety technical systems under certain circumstances confront clients and planners with a complicated problem [1]. Aspects such as the safety of tunnel users and the structure itself, life cycle costs for the structure and the relevant furnishing as well as the location and availability in the network make the choice of the correct furnishing variants a complex decision. In Part 2 the authors introduce a multi-criterial decision model, which was developed during the “Safety of Life in Tunnels – 2” (SOLIT²) project1 sponsored by the Federal Economics Ministry (BMWi).

It enables decisions to be taken in a controlled and transparent manner taking the cited general conditions and criteria into account. Taking the example of a concrete model tunnel it is displayed how the technical and economic efficiency of competing furnishing variants can be comparatively assessed in a transparent and equitable manner. The developments presented here are to be found for example in the “Guideline for the holistic Appraisal of Tunnels with Fire Fighting Systems as well as their Planning”, which can be downloaded from the homepage of the SOLIT Consortium under

Decision Model in the course of SOLIT2


Within the framework of the SOLIT2 project among other things the alternative configuration possibilities through the application of a water mist fire fighting system (FFFS/WN-BBA) with regard to the safety technical furnishing of a road tunnel were examined. The aim was to enable different furnishing variants to be compared with respect to the protective aims presented in Part 1 of this publication. Towards this end, various decision models were appraised and examined with respect to their capacity for adaptation within the described context. Many...

Related articles:

Issue 2013-08

Decision Model for Furnishing Tunnels with safety technical Systems Part 1: General Conditions for Transportation Tunnels

Introduction Determining the furnishing of a transportation tunnel involves manifold decisions under differing premises during the planning phase. This primarily relates to the regulations drawn up by...

Issue 2012-01

Fixed Fire Fighting Systems for Road and Rail Tunnels

1 Fixed Fire Fighting Systems (FFFS) in Tunnels 1.1 Introduction Fixed fire fighting systems (FFFS) are an active way of combating fires in tunnels (Fig. 1). They are a new method of improving fire...

Issue 2015-08 Technical and economic marginal Conditions

Upgrading Tunnels through active Fire-Fighting Systems – Part 1

1 Introduction In recent years new guidelines for tunnel safety with stricter demands relating to safety levels have been introduced or are under preparation both nationally and throughout Europe....

Issue 2021-04

Economic Efficiency of Fixed Fire Fighting Systems for Road Tunnels

Prerequisites According to the current German regulations [1], structural fire protection in road tunnels should essentially be realised by adding polypropylene fibres to the structural concrete (PP...

Issue 2013-07 fire fighting systems | UK

Dartford Crossing: High-Pressure Water Mist Technology sets new Standards in Tunnel Safety

Starting Position The Dartford Crossing, a complex comprising 2 tunnel bores (Fig. 1) and a cable-stayed bridge in the east of London, links Grays in Essex on the north side with Dartford (Kent) on...